[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"reply:7317":3},{"id":4,"product_id":5,"user_id":6,"is_deleted":7,"root_id":4,"content":8,"images":292,"create_at":293,"update_at":293,"vote_value":294,"reply_count":295,"user":296,"stats":302,"product":306,"emoji_reacts":315,"status":6,"prev_id":214,"next_id":214,"parent_id":312,"tags":319,"user_remark":312,"user_favorite":7},7317,657,1,false,{"content":9,"type":291},[10,19,30,31,39,47,48,68,84,85,89,90,104,105,123,124,132,133,137,138,152,153,157,158,174,175,195,196,222,223,245,246,260,261,275,276,280,281],{"content":11,"type":18},[12],{"content":13,"type":17},[14],{"text":15,"type":16},"当评价有了售价，当攻略变成了打卡指南，所有的推荐都会失真。","text","paragraph","blockquote",{"content":20,"type":17},[21,23,28],{"text":22,"type":16},"昨天在小红书上刷到一篇帖子，是前马蜂窝的员工发的，文章大意是",{"marks":24,"text":27,"type":16},[25],{"type":26},"bold","：MFW 时代过去后，搜攻略越来越费劲，越来越不知道怎么玩。引起了不少共鸣和追忆。",{"text":29,"type":16},"大抵是夜深 emo 时，我也感慨万千（原帖链接放在文末）。",{"type":17},{"content":32,"type":17},[33,37],{"marks":34,"text":36,"type":16},[35],{"type":26},"旅行，是件很个性化的事。",{"text":38,"type":16},"这次国庆我和对象来了个说走就走的环浙江自驾游，只定了个大致的路线，嵊州 -> 临海 -> 苍南 -> 义乌 -> 随机，诚然没有一个 AI 旅行产品能胜任这个任务，于是我拆散了，每个地区各来一个规划。",{"content":40,"type":17},[41,43],{"text":42,"type":16},"但结果不尽我意，这或许是大多数 AI 旅游产品的通病：出行没有自驾、酒店不考虑预算、",{"marks":44,"text":46,"type":16},[45],{"type":26},"数据来源于小红书。",{"type":17},{"content":49,"type":17},[50,52,56,58,62,64],{"text":51,"type":16},"是的，“数据来源于小红书” 在我看来是难做好旅游攻略的一大问题，因为在小红书上的游玩攻略，不",{"marks":53,"text":55,"type":16},[54],{"type":26},"是讲旅行的感受，而是怎么出片。",{"text":57,"type":16},"我还记的几年前流行过一个词，叫",{"marks":59,"text":61,"type":16},[60],{"type":26},"“种草”",{"text":63,"type":16},"，但如今在我看来，大多数攻略帖子，是",{"marks":65,"text":67,"type":16},[66],{"type":26},"“暗广”。",{"content":69,"type":17},[70,72,76,78,82],{"text":71,"type":16},"一方面，大家都推荐的，或许说明确实不错。但另一方面，",{"marks":73,"text":75,"type":16},[74],{"type":26},"很难保证这个推荐是没有经过充值的。",{"text":77,"type":16},"经常下馆子的朋友都知道，有时候餐馆会有打卡、写好评送小饮品小食的活动，像我这种贪小便宜的人肯定是会参与一下的。所以",{"marks":79,"text":81,"type":16},[80],{"type":26},"这类附赠小恩小惠的评价，增加了辨别攻略靠谱程度的负担。",{"text":83,"type":16},"我经常看了好多帖子，但还是不知道该怎么玩......",{"type":17},{"content":86,"type":17},[87],{"text":88,"type":16},"我出门玩主要 2 个点，行程松弛（比如临近中午才开始玩）和住宿花小钱办大事。",{"type":17},{"content":91,"type":17},[92,96,98,102],{"marks":93,"text":95,"type":16},[94],{"type":26},"AI 无法给出适合的旅游行程。",{"text":97,"type":16},"拿我前两天苍南的行程举例吧，我走的是苍南 168 公路黄金海岸线，大多数帖子都是推荐从北往南，从崇家岙出发，到霞关结束，中途睡一宿 2 天 1 夜。但是看一眼地图就会发现，从北往南走，是靠着山体的，主驾要开车不能看海景，副驾要看海景得绕过主驾和对向车流。那为什么不从南往北呢？主驾开车的时候就能看到海景，副驾更的视野更是一点障碍都没有。于是疯狂的搜索最终找到近似路线的攻略帖子，这个靠 AI 生成攻略是做不出来的，",{"marks":99,"text":101,"type":16},[100],{"type":26},"因为这个线路它不够大众",{"text":103,"type":16},"，检索后得到的权重就不够高，就不会出现在最终攻略里。",{"type":17},{"content":106,"type":17},[107,111,113,121],{"marks":108,"text":110,"type":16},[109],{"type":26},"AI 无法给出有个性的攻略。由于每个人的喜好都不同，而这个喜好是没法通过主动或被动收集数据沉淀出来的。",{"text":112,"type":16},"比如攻略帖子里不会讲苍南 168 公路沿线景点推荐的游玩时间，更不会讲每个热门沙滩景色和项目都大同小异。虽然我参考做了 2 天 1 夜中途睡一宿的行程，但实际是花了 2h 玩了第一个沙滩后，就不想玩后续几个沙滩了，2 天的行程一天就玩完了，然后直接改计划直奔市区。（这里我就要小小吐槽一下 ",{"attrs":114,"type":120},{"id":115,"label":116,"mentionSuggestionChar":117,"objectType":118,"slug":119},640,"Gooh旅记","@","product","gooh-lv-ji","mention",{"text":122,"type":16}," 了，虽然画风可爱，但是免费版权益不是很够，每天只能创建 5 个行程卡片，对于这种沿线很多景点的场景就用的很难受）",{"type":17},{"content":125,"type":17},[126,130],{"marks":127,"text":129,"type":16},[128],{"type":26},"AI 无法给出有用的攻略。",{"text":131,"type":16},"当然我也不能免俗，去了几个网红打卡点，风景是不错，但是帖子里没讲的是，车特别难停！！！要么不讲，要么就说停路边，即使加了国庆的关键词，也不会说类似于 “无尽蓝总店，多往前开 50m 就有一个停车场” 这类真的对自驾特别有用的攻略。",{"type":17},{"content":134,"type":17},[135],{"text":136,"type":16},"上面是 AI 旅游攻略难以满足我行程的几个点，这些内容都不会出现在大多数帖子攻略里，毕竟大多数是打卡推荐。",{"type":17},{"content":139,"type":17},[140,142,146,148],{"text":141,"type":16},"下面讲一讲",{"marks":143,"text":145,"type":16},[144],{"type":26},"住宿",{"text":147,"type":16},"，对我来说一直是一个老大难的问题。毕竟还没富到无脑选度假村级别的那种，基本考虑的是 200-300 区间的酒店或者民宿。这个价位的酒店水平，可以说是开盲盒。有些能住的特别爽（在沈阳定了一个电竞民宿和在苏州定的一个民宿，装修和硬件都特别合适，南昌站附近有一个老旧老旧的也挺不错的，不仅房间大交通便利，房间还有一个大大的摇椅特别爽，可惜后面再没遇到了），有些就是大冤种。",{"marks":149,"text":151,"type":16},[150],{"type":26},"那如何避免开盲盒呢？就是看评价。",{"type":17},{"content":154,"type":17},[155],{"text":156,"type":16},"但是啊，小红书推荐的，不是广告就是人均大几百的，完全没法做参考意见，高德有时候比较价格划算但是评价数特别少。飞猪、携程这类的 OTA 产品，我也不常用嫌占存储，所以大多数很依赖美团（毕竟经常点外卖）和高德（看地图距离）。我会特别关注差评，毕竟如果有硬伤（即不干净不卫生有烟臭空调不给力还有交通不便利）就会直接 pass。",{"type":17},{"content":159,"type":17},[160,162,166,168,172],{"text":161,"type":16},"诶那这时候 AI 能派上用场么？很可惜还是不行。",{"marks":163,"text":165,"type":16},[164],{"type":26},"一是因为推荐的个数太少",{"text":167,"type":16},"，不如我直接在列表里看，在 APP 里还能看看交通和周边。",{"marks":169,"text":171,"type":16},[170],{"type":26},"二是我挑住宿就是挑装修环境",{"text":173,"type":16},"，这个主观的喜好还是得亲自看图，特别是住客的图，所以用 AI 反而是降低效率。另外上文也说了，这个价位的酒店是盲盒。我先在横店一个酒店里写这篇猹评，它没有出现在小红书的攻略里，因为大家推荐的是官方的景酒套餐比较划算，2 天 1 晚差不多 1k 多，而包含的酒店可能还存在加价和满房的情况。而我这个，不仅靠近景点，价格还便宜，才 147，甚至有摩天轮可以看。让 AI 推荐的话，大多是景酒套餐里包含的那几个景区里的酒店了，虽然是很有横店特色但的确能有更省钱的方案......",{"type":17},{"content":176,"type":17},[177,179,183,185,189,191],{"text":178,"type":16},"最后讲讲",{"marks":180,"text":182,"type":16},[181],{"type":26},"吃",{"text":184,"type":16},"。这个就是美图 & 大众点评、高德扫街榜打架的地方了，小红书的攻略则还是一如既往的出片出片打卡打卡。我的感受是，",{"marks":186,"text":188,"type":16},[187],{"type":26},"跟着榜单、评分、攻略走不至于踩雷，但是缺少了一点烟火气。",{"text":190,"type":16},"它们不会说，这里的老板特别热情喜欢吆喝、这里的街区开车各凭本事（亲眼目睹了一场车祸的发生）饭馆附近停车特别难（哦对突然想起上面订酒店的场景，很多主打免费停车的，并不是有自己的停车场，而是路边停靠.... 我踩了好几个雷了）。",{"marks":192,"text":194,"type":16},[193],{"type":26},"这些和出行息息相关的细节，很少出现在一个攻略帖里，也自然的不会被 AI 知道。",{"type":17},{"content":197,"type":17},[198,200,202,204,208,210,220],{"text":199,"type":16},"只能说这是时代趋势，许多人在那位老哥的帖子里怀念过去马蜂窝里官方的攻略贴、蜂首们的游记，怀念那真挚的表达。现在节奏越来越快，碎片化的时间让人无法沉下心来看完动辄几千上万字的游记攻略，我们好像都在追求用最少的时间达到一个高质量的结果。我们比谁的响应时间更短，谁的迭代更快，谁单位时间能吞吐更多的 token 量。",{"type":201},"hardBreak",{"text":203,"type":16},"比如这个 ",{"marks":205,"text":207,"type":16},[206],{"type":26},"AI 小蚂 ",{"text":209,"type":16},"做个攻略，花了至少 20min，我都觉得慢，但以前研究明白这一切可能需要三四天（有趣的事，小蚂居然是写了一个网页攻略 hhh ",{"marks":211,"text":219,"type":16},[212],{"attrs":213,"type":218},{"class":214,"href":215,"rel":216,"target":217},null,"https:\u002F\u002Fm.mafengwo.cn\u002Fyetachat\u002Fagent\u002Freport?id=d416297c52e081a49d150ff65d933d6a&mfw_chid=2578-151782930&oth_chid_data=4ce1c4d8-2fe9-4ea1-bc68-2b872f62196b","noopener noreferrer nofollow","_blank","link","横店明清宫苑古装情侣 2 日深度游",{"text":221,"type":16},"）。",{"type":17},{"content":224,"type":17},[225,227,231,233,237,239,243],{"text":226,"type":16},"可",{"marks":228,"text":230,"type":16},[229],{"type":26},"旅行，好像并不是一个追求速度的事情。",{"text":232,"type":16},"或者换句话说，所谓",{"marks":234,"text":236,"type":16},[235],{"type":26},"旅游",{"text":238,"type":16},",就是",{"marks":240,"text":242,"type":16},[241],{"type":26},"从自己呆腻的地方去看别人呆腻的地方",{"text":244,"type":16},"。去享受风景，去体验人文。做攻略的过程，是了解一个地方的过程，就比如我明天在横店玩，可没有一个攻略里提到清明上河图「片场中秋夜」这个特殊的活动。这个在官方号里有说，但如果不自己找，就不会通过攻略或者 AI 工具推荐所被动接受。AI 旅行工具为什么用完后还是不知道怎么玩？我猜是因为这里缺失了 “自己” 的真实想法，缺少了想要探索这个世界的冲动，缺少了为什么而出发。",{"type":17},{"content":247,"type":17},[248,252,254,258],{"marks":249,"text":251,"type":16},[250],{"type":26},"我觉得 AI 旅游产品，可能可以多讲解讲解景点背后的故事",{"text":253,"type":16},"，而不是做个小红书帖子整理员，毕竟帖子我自己会去看，我自己会去做筛选，我的上下文管理能力肯定比 llm 强，但知识面缺没有。",{"marks":255,"text":257,"type":16},[256],{"type":26},"马蜂窝也没很好的利用它本身的数据",{"text":259,"type":16},"，最终交付的攻略并没有比其他普通的 AI 产品强多少..... 比如至少配个图吧..........",{"type":17},{"content":262,"type":17},[263,265,269,271],{"text":264,"type":16},"看着马蜂窝、看着豆瓣，我也会常常想到观猹。",{"marks":266,"text":268,"type":16},[267],{"type":26},"真挚的感受变得越来越难以表达，真诚的评价变得越来越昂贵",{"text":270,"type":16},"，这也是观猹存在的意义，有这么个地方让大家对各类产品畅所欲言，",{"marks":272,"text":274,"type":16},[273],{"type":26},"让有价值的声音被更多人听见，是我们在努力的方向。",{"type":17},{"content":277,"type":17},[278],{"text":279,"type":16},"路还很长，环浙江自驾游也还有浙西未去，但到达不是目的，享受的是旅途中对未知未来的期待。",{"type":17},{"content":282,"type":17},[283,285],{"text":284,"type":16},"最后附几张图吧 😎 以及",{"marks":286,"text":290,"type":16},[287],{"attrs":288,"type":218},{"class":214,"href":289,"rel":216,"target":217},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.xiaohongshu.com\u002Fexplore\u002F68d52ffc000000000e00cdc2?xsec_source=pc_feed&note_flow_source=wechat","小红书帖子：真的怀念马蜂窝时代、穷游时代，现在的旅游攻略怎么这样？","doc","https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1759677176_076ed111-be9a-41d4-9f1a-87f17982f916.png;https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1759677176_dd8628f1-a83c-4518-b121-9ba5d38350e8.png;https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1759677176_3396ff34-c46c-4646-8d68-a7bb8ed305c3.png;https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1759677451_0699a32c-bbc9-4a15-8a15-aac83fcfc87b.jpg;https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1759677451_a1259e7d-c59d-45b5-9e9a-4110f17db207.jpg;https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1759677451_96f0507e-0e94-472b-bd49-ddf323a1d607.jpg;https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1759677516_2df013a5-43d5-4490-8089-b3413da32035.jpg;https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1759677516_e4caf54d-73d4-47eb-ad93-dc8a3d79f293.jpg;https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1759677451_b95edb2e-2403-4614-9617-798366d45897.jpg","2025-10-05T15:23:48.682Z",2,7,{"id":6,"nickname":297,"username":298,"avatar_url":299,"cover_url":300,"bio":301,"is_gold_member":7,"is_official":7},"溪河","l4walk","https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fprofile\u002Favatar\u002F1_1755783497443_user_1.png","https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F1_1784306211_a4c28767-381e-4bc3-b0ba-bde11c2f1e57.png","观察观猹",{"score":303,"upvotes":304,"interest_count":294,"reply_subtree_size":295,"update_at":305},0.000036313668217390555,12,"2026-07-31T05:34:08.693Z",["Reactive",307],{"id":5,"name":308,"slug":309,"slogan":310,"avatar_url":311,"owner_id":312,"_timestamp":313,"_updating":7,"_model":118,"_extra":314,"_prevState":-1},"AI 小蚂","ai-xiao-ma","马蜂窝推出的 AI 旅行助手。","https:\u002F\u002Fwatcha.tos-cn-beijing.volces.com\u002Fprod\u002Fuser\u002Fuploads\u002F10005545_1759225606_7fc06fc3-35f6-49df-aeb7-022219012247.png",0,1785447298050,{},{"reacts":316},[317],{"emoji_code":318,"count":294,"reacted":7},"❤️",[]]